|
Post by Onyango Oloo on Jan 8, 2016 17:33:38 GMT 3
Denis Galava the Managing Editor for Special Projects penned an editorial which appeared in the Daily Nation on January 2, 2016. He was immediately suspended. Keep in mind that that Kenya's largest circulation daily in NOT owned by Kenya government, but by the Aga Khan, a major private investor in Kenyan economy. Tom Mshindi, the NMG's Editor in Chief said this to explain the action: “We have asked Denis Galava, the Managing Editor for Special Projects, to take some time off to allow us time to review the circumstances of the writing and filing of the editorial for Saturday Nation, January 2, 2016.
"We are investigating whether proper consultation and review of the editorial material was done before the piece was sent to press.
“A full length editorial, a Page One commentary or an editorial expressing particularly strong views must first be discussed by senior editors in conference as well as with the Editor-in-Chief to prepare the leadership of the company to deal with the consequences, if any, of that publication.
“The lack of consultation where one writer takes a strong position on such an important issue single-handedly without broad discussion and consultation is a significant departure from established procedure.”
Later, in an interview with Odeo Sirari of BBC Swahili, Joe Muganda the Nation's CEO compared Galava to a "bank robber". Listen to audio file below: soundcloud.com/odeo-ekareut-sirari/interview-with-nation-media-groupd-ceo-joe-muganda-on-the-suspension-of-dennis-galava
|
|
|
Post by Onyango Oloo on Jan 8, 2016 18:19:20 GMT 3
The NMG's suspension of Galava led to a flurry of protests on social media:
|
|
|
Post by jakaswanga on Jan 8, 2016 20:49:08 GMT 3
methinks this something, which increasingly makes the commentator's seats a very hot one --boiling them over into a trenchant militancy otherwise not their cup of tea, has now entered the boardroom.
Tom Mshindi becomes a hyena at the crossroads. Suck up to power, or suck up to thought!?
So Tom Mshindi in saying is responding to, I am sure, advertisers pressure and their power-related hints.
Recently in the United Kingdom, a leading newspaper heavily dependent on advert from the HSBC bank, an whose owners were indebted to the same in other business and behind on repayment, completely ignored the big story in which the banking giant was found to have abetted tax-evasion and money laundering!
They killed the story as the saying goes! Problem is others covered the story, and the culprits were asked, why is this story not big by you guys?
They replied: that is our business, you do not tell us which stories to cover, nor how to cover them. Unconvinced, others peered deeper!
So a deeper look into Tom Mshindi reveals a scared CEO. That is okay in harsh economic times. The problem is if he tilts too far as he has, yet wants to keep up the appearances of a daily newspaper with and independent and objective reporting, as, O God, a newspaper like the daily nation ought ---with the erudite likes of Wiliam Ochieng' and Macharia Gaitho on board!
But he can still sleep easy, even the New York times was bribed if not bought by Dick Cheney to lie about weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, and uranium from Mauritania! It was a good business decision for the NYT, but a bad decision for its reputation. Since then, political blogs ran by independents have become the leading opinion shapers. The NYT is just another rumour site, but as an elite mouth piece, fatly patronised, enough to pay very well!
Not a bad prospect for the Daily Nation. Cutting edge commentary can be left to bloggers on the net. That is the international trend. Newspapers are hobbies for reclusive tycoons like the Aga Khan, Murdoch, or the above Barclay brothers, and they obey orders or go bust. They pay they have the say!
But Tom Mshindi cannot say that! (pay cheque gags!)
|
|
|
Post by kamalet on Jan 17, 2016 11:29:16 GMT 3
Happy new year folks!!!
It is actually very rich and hypocritical for Oloo to headline this thread as a media freedom issue!!
Many times he has had to eject posters on this forum for exactly the same reasons....failure to follow rules of the board.
In the Galava case, the media house has said that the problem they have is not to do with the contents of what he wrote, but failure to actually follow the rules of penning and publishing the editorial. NMG has published stuff a lot more critical from its political writers some of whom are clearly beneficiaries of brown envelopes so this "attack" on the president cannot surely be deemed the reason for the 'stepping aside' decision. Trying to bring in the foreign ownership angle only makes it worse.
The hypocrisy I see in this thread is amazing!
|
|
|
Post by Onyango Oloo on Jan 17, 2016 12:15:28 GMT 3
Happy new year folks!!! It is actually very rich and hypocritical for Oloo to headline this thread as a media freedom issue!! Many times he has had to eject posters on this forum for exactly the same reasons....failure to follow rules of the board. The hypocrisy I see in this thread is amazing! Kamalet:Although it is still early in the year, I think you are Jukwaa's runaway winner for the MOST HUMOUROUS post of 2016. Only you can TWIST the Galava issue completely out of recognition. A top editor is censored and censured from criticizing the Jubilee government. How can that be equivalent to kicking out a cyberdelinquent for sophomoric, reckless postings on Jukwaa?Onyango Oloo Administrator
|
|
|
Post by kamalet on Jan 18, 2016 20:18:30 GMT 3
Happy new year folks!!! It is actually very rich and hypocritical for Oloo to headline this thread as a media freedom issue!! Many times he has had to eject posters on this forum for exactly the same reasons....failure to follow rules of the board. The hypocrisy I see in this thread is amazing! Kamalet:Although it is still early in the year, I think you are Jukwaa's runaway winner for the MOST HUMOUROUS post of 2016. Only you can TWIST the Galava issue completely out of recognition. A top editor is censored and censured from criticizing the Jubilee government. How can that be equivalent to kicking out a cyberdelinquent for sophomoric, reckless postings on Jukwaa?Onyango Oloo AdministratorOloo The only thing that had me smiling in my post was the salutation for the new year! First Galava was not sacked he was suspended. Secondly the employers reason (perhaps you will call it an excuse) was that he did not follow the rules regarding editorials i.e. consultation by committee. Literary the man was hang out to dry by his editorial colleagues as they appear to have denied holding a meeting to discuss the contents prior to publication. The NMG Public Editor was at pains to explain the situation last Friday. The equivalence in the story to your expulsion of "cyberdeliquents" is that you have argued before that it was not the content that you chucked guys out for, but failure to follow rules of the board. You being a Raila adherent as are those 310/- followers of Pastor Kanyari have not expelled anyone critical of Raila, but you expelled those that criticised him in an uncivil manner.....still cannot see the difference or you are still laughing at something not funny?
|
|
|
Post by jakaswanga on Jan 18, 2016 21:54:31 GMT 3
Happy new year folks!!! It is actually very rich and hypocritical for Oloo to headline this thread as a media freedom issue!! Many times he has had to eject posters on this forum for exactly the same reasons....failure to follow rules of the board. The hypocrisy I see in this thread is amazing! Kamalet:Although it is still early in the year, I think you are Jukwaa's runaway winner for the MOST HUMOUROUS post of 2016. Only you can TWIST the Galava issue completely out of recognition. A top editor is censored and censured from criticizing the Jubilee government. How can that be equivalent to kicking out a cyberdelinquent for sophomoric, reckless postings on Jukwaa?Onyango Oloo Administrator Happy new Year folks! May be Oloo should revise the headline to include retired KANU-obsolete fossil Nkaissery! he ordered Boinett to arrest and jail anybody who shares photos of dead KA personnel in Somalia. That is now censorship!
|
|
|
Post by podp on Jan 18, 2016 22:45:21 GMT 3
Kamalet:Although it is still early in the year, I think you are Jukwaa's runaway winner for the MOST HUMOUROUS post of 2016. Only you can TWIST the Galava issue completely out of recognition. A top editor is censored and censured from criticizing the Jubilee government. How can that be equivalent to kicking out a cyberdelinquent for sophomoric, reckless postings on Jukwaa?Onyango Oloo Administrator Happy new Year folks! May be Oloo should revise the headline to include retired KANU-obsolete fossil Nkaissery! he ordered Boinett to arrest and jail anybody who shares photos of dead KA personnel in Somalia. That is now censorship! happy new 2016 with best wishes to Jukwaa contributors. thinking of the above highlighted. 'In Hungary, Ecuador, Turkey, Kenya, and elsewhere, officials are mimicking autocracies like Russia, Iran, or China by redacting critical news and building state media brands. They are also creating more subtle tools to complement the blunt instruments of attacking journalists. Stealth censorship appeals to authoritarian governments that want to appear like democracies—or at least not like old-style dictatorships. In illiberal democracies, of which there are a growing number, the government aims to keep a grip on the news media while concealing its fingerprints. A global survey of attacks on the press today shows governments mixing direct and indirect pressures as part of a booming emerging market in information control.' www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/02/government-censorship-21st-century-internet/385528/media owners face a difficult relationship with the government. When they approve stories containing potentially embarassing information, government officials often try to censor it. media.about.com/od/mediaethics/a/How-Media-Censorship-Affects-The-News.htmgoing back to 2007/2008 post election violence the excerpt below shows the dangers of censorship Preaching is not a journalist’s main job. Blatant fraud in a presidential election was clearly an urgent matter for the media and its journalists. But in the interests of restoring public order they deliberately chose to ignore it while thousands of Kenyans poured into the streets in search of “truth” and “justice.” After weeks of violence and killings that have exhausted the country, still nobody knows who really won the election, who cheated and how, and why social and tribal divisions cracked the foundations of the great Kenyan democracy that was seen as unbreakable. www.article19.org/data/files/pdfs/publications/kenya-how-far-to-go.pdfafter a brief dalliance between the media and Jubilee leadership in 2013, a reward for the former came. '"These media laws will force journalists and news outlets to self-censor to survive. They are a severe blow to investigative reporting in Kenya," cpj.org/2013/12/kenya-parliament-passes-draconian-media-laws.phpso the Interior CS is just applying what is on paper i.e. Act signed by PORK and the challenge of the Itumbis holed in the presidency is to try and hack into anyone who disobeys the CS
|
|
|
Post by kamalet on Jan 18, 2016 22:55:46 GMT 3
Kamalet:Although it is still early in the year, I think you are Jukwaa's runaway winner for the MOST HUMOUROUS post of 2016. Only you can TWIST the Galava issue completely out of recognition. A top editor is censored and censured from criticizing the Jubilee government. How can that be equivalent to kicking out a cyberdelinquent for sophomoric, reckless postings on Jukwaa?Onyango Oloo Administrator Happy new Year folks! May be Oloo should revise the headline to include retired KANU-obsolete fossil Nkaissery! he ordered Boinett to arrest and jail anybody who shares photos of dead KA personnel in Somalia. That is now censorship! why would we want publish pictures of dead KDF soldiers...glorification of their deaths or aiding the propaganda machinery of the al-kebabs? Did you see pictures of dead bodies in Paris..? There is something sensible called self censorship for the greater good and being a tactless and thoughtless society we have to inscribe it into LAW to deter the miscreants that think posting such photos is fun....ntk
|
|
|
Post by jakaswanga on Jan 19, 2016 20:01:54 GMT 3
Happy new Year folks! May be Oloo should revise the headline to include retired KANU-obsolete fossil Nkaissery! he ordered Boinett to arrest and jail anybody who shares photos of dead KA personnel in Somalia. That is now censorship! why would we want publish pictures of dead KDF soldiers...glorification of their deaths or aiding the propaganda machinery of the al-kebabs? Did you see pictures of dead bodies in Paris..? There is something sensible called self censorship for the greater good and being a tactless and thoughtless society we have to inscribe it into LAW to deter the miscreants that think posting such photos is fun....ntk Kamalet, Why would we want to publish the photos of the dead at war? you ask! Such are newsworthy, and we humans have a morbid curiosity to be satisfied, not to mention a healthy Voyeurism. War porn is very attractive, and that is why war films are ever popular. Death and forms of it are fascinating to man. We all know we will die eventually, but do not know how, and so we humans are mighty curious how others are after they are done, met their fates, especially very dramatic ones. It moves us emotionally, in empathy, disgust, horror or whatever. We just cannot help that because we are human. No, I did not see dead bodies of Paris. But I also know why, ever since the Vietnam war, the American army adopted to show a false view of war. Embedded journalists who report what the army wants reported, not what is. When the public see for real what war is, they do not want to send their children to it. A real picture of war undermines morale, and worse, if it is a war in a foreign country and you are filling body bags for the journey home.People then ask a disturbing question: what really are we doing there? Is it worth it? Is there a less horrendous way to achieve our aims? Is it really worth sacrifing our sons in a foreign land whose parliament has voted to kick us out!? The French authorities did not, can not let heaps of dead Frenchmen be seen in Paris. The public backlash would very well be the end of men like Hollande. Kamalet, it was fear which informed the censorship, not good taste ---you know the words of the French Anthem!? And closer to home too, it is fear which informs Nkaissery's gag. The pictures of ordinary Somalis - whom we are there to save from terrorism and should supposedly be thankful, dragging dead young Kenyan soldiers in black-hawk down reminiscent scenes, would raise a question at the back of every Kenyan' mind; a question outside the competence of our rulers. There is a mind-game going on, and controlling images is a life and death fight. Keep alert Kamalet, know to separate the real from the official reasons given by power for a decision to control information.
|
|
|
Post by Onyango Oloo on Jan 20, 2016 12:24:40 GMT 3
|
|
mashazack
New Member
Great to be here
Posts: 1
|
Post by mashazack on Jan 20, 2016 13:19:32 GMT 3
|
|
|
Post by kamalet on Jan 20, 2016 22:58:33 GMT 3
And 'thankfully' in an act of discipline NMG fires Galava who goes on twitter to announce he has been sacked.
This sad event shows the lack of wisdom in some of our journalists - he made a mistake of not consulting (as opposed to one of criticising) but since active opposition members and their lynch mob were convinced the was being harassed for daring challenge the president, he now thinks he is some kind of celeb.
Which is why the mzungu said that people living in glass house never throw stones! Poor Galava lived of a salary (unless this was supplemented by brown envelopes)and it is on record unless you are a radio DJ with a massive following (and ratings) writer journalists are paid a pittance and barely make ends meet. So our Galava is out of a job and must hope that some big media house will pick him up to carry on the job of calling the president out - if this does not work out he has to find a way of feeding himself and his family. Which begs the question, at what point do you make a sacrifice for a pointless cause at the risk of your own personal well being?
|
|
|
Post by mwalimumkuu on Jan 21, 2016 18:57:33 GMT 3
And 'thankfully' in an act of discipline NMG fires Galava who goes on twitter to announce he has been sacked. This sad event shows the lack of wisdom in some of our journalists - he made a mistake of not consulting (as opposed to one of criticising) but since active opposition members and their lynch mob were convinced the was being harassed for daring challenge the president, he now thinks he is some kind of celeb. Which is why the mzungu said that people living in glass house never throw stones! Poor Galava lived of a salary (unless this was supplemented by brown envelopes)and it is on record unless you are a radio DJ with a massive following (and ratings) writer journalists are paid a pittance and barely make ends meet. So our Galava is out of a job and must hope that some big media house will pick him up to carry on the job of calling the president out - if this does not work out he has to find a way of feeding himself and his family. Which begs the question, at what point do you make a sacrifice for a pointless cause at the risk of your own personal well being? Allegations have been made (especially by Senator Kipchumba Murkomen who even declared on national TV that he was willing to take both political and legal responsibility for his assertions, which have not been challenged by anyone including Galava himself), that the so called editorial was written elsewhere (the supposed author had nothing to do with NMG) and passed on to Galava for publication. By Tom Mshindi coming out to claim that there were no discussions on the publication or otherwise of the said piece, it gave credence to the view than Galava did what he did for his own reasons. Was he paid by forces outside NMG for the piece? For what reasons? What does it say about him as a professional? Is there any employer out there who cares about their reputation, business processes and procedures that could keep such a loose canon on their payroll? ~~ Mwalimumkuu @nyumbakubwa ~~
|
|
|
Post by jakaswanga on Jan 25, 2016 20:46:09 GMT 3
Happy new year folks!!! It is actually very rich and hypocritical for Oloo to headline this thread as a media freedom issue!! Many times he has had to eject posters on this forum for exactly the same reasons....failure to follow rules of the board. The hypocrisy I see in this thread is amazing! Kamalet:Although it is still early in the year, I think you are Jukwaa's runaway winner for the MOST HUMOUROUS post of 2016. Only you can TWIST the Galava issue completely out of recognition. A top editor is censored and censured from criticizing the Jubilee government. How can that be equivalent to kicking out a cyberdelinquent for sophomoric, reckless postings on Jukwaa?Onyango Oloo Administrator Onyango Oloo Yo,This thread of yours is becoming an uncomfortable fit, like a womb meant for a single baby suddenly housing quintuplets and swelling in rapid growth. Conside the following ---all to do I think with MEDIA FREEDOM IN KENYA, AND JUBILEE'S TAKE. Is there enough data pursuing censorship to talk about an established/FACTUAL tendency? A tendency to persecution, persecuting even if not prosecuting those disseminating information the government would rather hide? A tendency widespread enough as to prove a decided state of general intimidation? A mobilised judicial apparatus to cut off tongues? ---we already saw Nkaissery foaming in the mouth fingering blogger Yassin Juma, formerly of Nation media house. when odd-ball-hard-ball nutty ex Generals like Nkai- foam at you ... that is not nothing! Here is some recent data. So, Oloo, where are we? Corporate boardrooms in concert with an increasingly authoritarian regime? Remember Joe Kadhi? he was arrested for a front page editorial denouncing the one party state! --I guarantee Uhuru Kenyatta does not recognise he is repeating old steps. And there are ven sayings about that: farce, tragedy and the rest!
|
|