|
Post by Onyango Oloo on Feb 10, 2014 23:54:16 GMT 3
|
|
|
Post by OtishOtish on Feb 11, 2014 1:31:31 GMT 3
|
|
|
Post by omundustrong on Feb 11, 2014 8:12:35 GMT 3
Great piece OO,informative too,it is this kind of religious intolerance that is a recipe for conflicts that are currently being experienced at the Coast.The Sikh community,if my memory serves me right have done alot of community projects in this country that needs to be lauded.The last thing you want to see is a group of youths drunk on whatever substance try to justify hooliganism.
|
|
|
Post by kamalet on Feb 11, 2014 8:28:01 GMT 3
The issue in Kisumu was not about Sikhs or Hindus and their god whatever he is perceived to be. The issue is simple one of religious insensitivity.
I highly doubt a statue of Jesus and Mary in the middle of Eastleigh or in Lamu would go down very well with the locals.
Insensitive actions tend to lead to unreasonable reactions as was the case in Kisumu. In a town that has many christians and muslims none of whom apart from their places of worship has put up some religious statue, it was inevitable that the actions of a minority religious group would lead to the reaction that we saw in Kisumu. Nothing stops the sikhs from putting up their religious symbols inside and around their temples, nothing should stop the sikhs from having processions in the town marking important dates in their religion such as Vaisakhi - the point here being they are exercising their constitution right to freedom of worship.
So address the cause and you never have to worry about the result.
And just in case you were wondering Oloo, Protestants and Catholics are all christian....but they profess their faith in very different ways. That is why you would be lynched if you attempted to bring in the statue of Holy Mary into the St. Andrews Church, Nairobi!
|
|
|
Post by Onyango Oloo on Feb 11, 2014 12:54:22 GMT 3
Comments from the blog:
3 comments:
Mbugua said...
2:09 AM Khalsa Lakhvir-SINGH said...
Anonymous said...
|
|
|
Post by Onyango Oloo on Feb 11, 2014 21:32:49 GMT 3
I have been commenting on racism for years: groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/africa-oped/conversations/messages/7763 Another Rejoinder to a Kenyan Racist Online (7763) Onyango Oloo Feb 1 4:14 PM Return-Path: <oloo_wa_canada@...> X-Sender: oloo_wa_canada@... X-Apparently-To: africa-oped@yahoogroups.com Date: Sun, 01 Feb 2004 21:14:54 -0000 To: africa-oped@yahoogroups.com
|
|
|
Post by jakaswanga on Feb 11, 2014 21:42:23 GMT 3
The issue in Kisumu was not about Sikhs or Hindus and their god whatever he is perceived to be. The issue is simple one of religious insensitivity. I highly doubt a statue of Jesus and Mary in the middle of Eastleigh or in Lamu would go down very well with the locals. Insensitive actions tend to lead to unreasonable reactions as was the case in Kisumu. In a town that has many christians and muslims none of whom apart from their places of worship has put up some religious statue, it was inevitable that the actions of a minority religious group would lead to the reaction that we saw in Kisumu. Nothing stops the sikhs from putting up their religious symbols inside and around their temples, nothing should stop the sikhs from having processions in the town marking important dates in their religion such as Vaisakhi - the point here being they are exercising their constitution right to freedom of worship. So address the cause and you never have to worry about the result. And just in case you were wondering Oloo, Protestants and Catholics are all christian....but they profess their faith in very different ways. That is why you would be lynched if you attempted to bring in the statue of Holy Mary into the St. Andrews Church, Nairobi! I tend to agree with you Kamalet. Religious statues ---Sikhism being a religion which coincides with ethnicity like Judaism—should be confined to the private entities of those religions [church compound, temple compound, synagogue shrine, mosque compound]. Public places I want to reserved for humans ! Yes I am for idolatry in public places! Like the statue of Carey Francis [who was that you ask] at Kenyatta Sportsground in Kisumu; the statue of Dedan Kimathi at Kimathi street Nairobi; the statue of Tom Mboya, or Jomo Kenyatta in their respective streets in Nairobi; the unknown soldier. And hopefully soon, Ojijo Koteko in Kendu-Bay, and Lwanda Magere at Awasi. But a statue of Mohamed, or the Budha, or Jesus like this Rio de Jeneiro landmark? on a PUBLIC SQUARE/PLACE?? Then I will ask Karangi and the KDF to do to it what the Talibhan under Mullah Omar did to the Budhas of Bamiyan, 240 km from Kabul. Never since the Islamic conquest of Egypt in which the Muslims tried to chisel out the Sphinx of Giza, has the world witnessed such a barbaric act of cultural vandalism. But hey, the issue being avoided in Kisumu, is the poor race relations between Indians and blacks. In 100 years of existing together, these communities have not managed to produce a single interracial wedding! Sociologically speaking, that is a significant statistic. Apartheid? NB: There is reason to come up with a good understanding of the increasing militant puritan, fundamentalist tendency in world religions. God's case no appeal, Achebe once joked! ThAT is why god's people scare me. They are always right. Actually it was Napoleon of France who ordered his troops to use the nose of the Sphinx for target practice! It is the French, not the Muslims, who vandalised the Sphinx. Next time you catch a French lady twitching her nose at the Talibhan of Afghanistan, remind them of just how primitive the French under the great Napoleon were, destroying the wornder of the world, the Sphinx!
|
|
|
Post by OtishOtish on Feb 11, 2014 21:54:59 GMT 3
Kamale, "reliable" as usual, writes that I highly doubt a statue of Jesus and Mary in the middle of Eastleigh or in Lamu would go down very well with the locals. Jesus? Mary? The Hindu or Sikh or Hindu-Sikh "god" didn't look like any "religious" personality I can think of. As it turns out, I have bought a couple of "abstract praying figures" that look very much like that one, the only difference being in the positioning of the hands. What's more, I bought them in Kisumu, not far from where the "Hindu Sikh God" was being stoned. I bought them on the basis that they were "premium & authentic Kisii carvings", but I am now examining them carefully to find out whose gods they are. I may need a microscope. Here you have a point. If religious intolerance can be addressed, we will not have to worry about this sort of thing.
|
|
|
Post by jakaswanga on Feb 11, 2014 22:04:21 GMT 3
We have been having some purification rituals. The Legio Maria group organised a very big one which calmed the nerves of the town. The story goes like this. First you remember the woman who was saved from lynching and a witch-burning ceremony by the police some time back? Folks claimed she was a ''shetani'' and had been caught draining blood from neighbourhood children. Thereafter, a curfew fell over the town, especially on the bodaboda trade. Word was, the woman had left a nest, and the nest hat matured. There were creatures in town in the form of humans; but in the dark as they rode the boda, they turned into ferocious wolves which bit the necks of the rides through. The Kenya police with their trigger-happy sharp-shooters could not calm nerves. So the Legio Maria priests took charge. With success! But the Legio is a controversial sect as you know. Melkizedek Ondetto has the rank of a Messiah, and that is the same rank as Jesus Christ. But there is also the new kid in town, Prophet Owuor. And competition will be competition! Yes, Kisumu is a heavily Christian town. I have attended an evangelical gathering with star canadian priests whose chief message was: burn homos! ---and the crowd roared in affirmation!
|
|
|
Post by OtishOtish on Feb 11, 2014 23:19:03 GMT 3
But hey, the issue being avoided in Kisumu, is the poor race relations between Indians and blacks. In 100 years of existing together, these communities have not managed to produce a single interracial wedding!
This poor "race relations" is an issue worth looking at. But I don't put much stock in the inter-racial "where your women at?". Look around cities and towns in Kenya---Kisumu, Eldoret, Nakuru, etc. How many marriageable young "Indian-Kenyan" women are there to go around, and how many young "Asian" men are in need? The phenomenon of insularity in such cases is not any different from what would be observed with minorities in just about any part of the world, and the "Indian-Kenyans" in Kenya are actually a very tiny group relative to the size of the country's population. Events such as the one being discussed are hardly going to encourage the "Indians" to hand over their women to what they see as crazed stoners. (Real stones, not getting stoned, which would actually be preferable.)
Continuing from the last sentence, take a look at the larger tribes in Kenya. Once you get out of places like Nairobi, how much inter-tribal marriage is there to be found? And should we foment inter-tribal hatred, or allow it to thrive, on that basis? 100 years? In my own lifetime, I can remember a time when a Luo marrying "outside" was considered really bad, and, I imagine, that would be the case with other tribes. A Luhya or a Kisii might have "sneaked" in, but a Luo who married, say, a Kikuyu or a mzungu was definitely "lost". Might as well be dead.
Today there are increasingly more "inter-tribal" marriages in Kenya. But what do they amount to? Look around during elections, when its "our man" and "our people". Women and children will get burned like firewood, because they are "foreigners who stole our land", and from the other side similar atrocities ...
That the race relations are in poor shape is in no doubt, and it's not just in Kisumu. Part of the problem is actually very simple: envy of economic success. That part could be dealt with by one side not flaunting its success and perhaps giving more and the other side trying harder for its own success. As regards the latter, too often the locals who start businesses quickly proceed to be Mr. Big at the local bars, daily ordering drinks for the house and buying malayas by the dozen. It's not a solid foundation on which business can thrive, and many don't thrive.
A cheap and very effective way in which in inter-racial relations could improved is in daily interactions. During colonial times, there were places with signs stating that "Africans, dogs, and children not allowed". My observation---first-hand, in quite a few Kenyan towns--is that when it comes to their employees and customers, some "Indian-Kenyans" appear to operate on the basis that "Africans, dogs, and children are allowed; but they will be treated like Africans, dogs, and children". That's happening even now in 2014, and the hidden resentment is a good replacement for anyone looking for gunpowder but unable to find it.
Clearly, there are problems on both sides. A great deal of tolerance and get-along attitudes need to be built. Having lived in places*** where I was part of a very tiny minority, I would put the larger part of the burden on the majority; otherwise, the minority, on its part, simply becomes more insular. And on and on it goes, with the majority continually puzzled that "they still won't hand over their women!" ... never mind that some of those asking are wolves (Jakaswanga excluded). A starting good starting point would be some knowledge: it doesn't help when people think that Hindus and Sikhs are just "the same Indian lot", know nothing about their religious beliefs and practices, but have no doubts when they sight a "god" from .... even when similar "gods" and "idols" are routinely sold just down the street---by the "real" Kenyans and to the "real" Kenyans! Even on eBay they are routinely sold, with what appears to be great "pride" and "this-is-the-real-Kenyan thing".
A country like Kenya need to work very hard at "tolerance"---tribal, racial, religious, etc. Otherwise all that there exists is a collection of little powder-kegs waiting for a match. ________________________________________________________________________________________ *** Places where it is assumed that Africans do very bizarre things. How does anyone know? Well, just look at them! They are Africans! So it was said ... Perhaps they in mind things like:
www.the-star.co.ke/news/article-131987/why-night-runners-are-seeking-state-recognition
(I think all forms of exercise are good for the health, and no doubt one feels "really free" when running around naked. But kicking door and stones on the roof is definitely bizarre ... many of these people are "good, upright Christians.)
|
|
|
Post by ebarasi on Feb 12, 2014 0:59:36 GMT 3
This issue just goes to show how intolerance has grown, not only in Kenya but everywhere. As long as we accept an individual or a group as part of the society, then that individual or group has a right to occupy public space. By that I mean, practice their culture, Religion included. Isn't the tolling of the church bells or the the call to prayer from the minaret well beyond the confines of the church or mosque an occupation of public space? The idea of hiding or practicing one's religion in the closet and playing someone else in the public space is an attempt at encouraging hypocrisy to assuage the thirst of ignorance. If religion and culture be the carrier of the norms by which you view the world, by what standard do you view the world when you have shed your glasses when out of the closet?
|
|
|
Post by OtishOtish on Feb 12, 2014 1:17:46 GMT 3
This issue just goes to show how intolerance has grown, not only in Kenya but everywhere. As long as we accept an individual or a group as part of the society, then that individual or group has a right to occupy public space. By that I mean, practice their culture, Religion included. Isn't the tolling of the church bells or the the call to prayer from the minaret well beyond the confines of the church or mosque an occupation of public space? The idea of hiding or practicing one's religion in the closet and playing someone else in the public space is an attempt at encouraging hypocrisy to assuage the thirst of ignorance. If religion and culture be the carrier of the norms by which you view the world, by what standard do you view the world when you have shed your glasses when out of the closet? Point.
|
|
|
Post by nowayhaha on Feb 14, 2014 10:10:49 GMT 3
This issue just goes to show how intolerance has grown, not only in Kenya but everywhere. As long as we accept an individual or a group as part of the society, then that individual or group has a right to occupy public space. By that I mean, practice their culture, Religion included. Isn't the tolling of the church bells or the the call to prayer from the minaret well beyond the confines of the church or mosque an occupation of public space? The idea of hiding or practicing one's religion in the closet and playing someone else in the public space is an attempt at encouraging hypocrisy to assuage the thirst of ignorance. If religion and culture be the carrier of the norms by which you view the world, by what standard do you view the world when you have shed your glasses when out of the closet?
|
|